My Mom died far too young. There really isn't a 'nice' way to say it. One thing I have found to be very helpful in my process of grieving is writing. So - whether you are a friend, or a stranger - I hope that what I share here helps you to understand the process I am working through. Or, that it brings you comfort to know you are not alone in your experiences with 'loss'. Enjoy!

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Nature vs. Nurture (Or to Hell with both)


Whether we want to admit it or not, we are the product of our parents (and therefore, their gene pools), as well as the nurturing in our raising (or lack thereof). We can deny it and fight this reality all we want, but deep down, apples don’t fall far from trees. And, even when the apple gets picked up and moved elsewhere, there’s still an unspoken influence that comes with it.

That doesn’t mean we’re doomed to be just like our parents. Quite the contrary. Let us not forget that our parents are imperfect like all other beings who walk the Earth, us included. Perfection is impossible (thank goodness). Our parents, no matter how wonderful and/or flawed, have gifts and qualities that we should embrace and be proud of. If we happen to inherit traits from them that we aren’t so thrilled about, we can learn to navigate them, censor them, or channel them to be positive or useful. Those are choices we make, that don’t happen overnight. It isn’t easy, it isn’t a one-time thing; It’s a lifelong choice of commitment, should we recognize - and accept - the challenge.

I spent so much of my childhood trying to be a peaceful participant. Often that was within the walls of my own childhood home (where just my Mom and I lived for 24 years). It doesn’t seem like a complicated dynamic to participate in, but my Mom was one of the most complicated people I’ve ever known (in mostly good ways) which meant it sometimes felt like I was living with more than one person. I was her child, but also her ‘spouse’, roommate, friend, confidante, etc. I grew up long before I should have had to, but never knew this was strange compared to taken for granted norms.

I also tried to be the peaceful participant in my parents’ divorce. Like most children in broken families, I felt it was my fault that their partnership had faltered. The weight and burden that brings is suffocating, and as far back as I can remember, I tried to be the ‘perfect child’ in order to earn their love and forgiveness. Some children rebel out of anger and frustration. I, on the other hand, conformed out of guilt and fear. I wanted desperately for both of them to accept me, cherish me and be proud of me. There even came a time where I would have taken all of the above from just one of them, if only one would express that. For too long a stretch I doubted that either of them felt any of these things, and yet I persevered. Straight A’s, no trouble, big smile. I love and forgive them both, but now know – looking back - how incredibly wrong and heartbreakingly sad that was. At this stage of my life, I look back on it all as if it is playing out on a television screen, and I am but a bystander. That little person is someone I want to reach out to hug and reassure, but it’s as if ‘she’ isn’t me.

A friend recently posted this YouTube video, and it resonated to my core. It’s heart-wrenching and raw, but so relatable, for those who have experienced divorce as a child.


I also tried to be a peaceful participant within the walls of my Dad’s long-time second family. I was the resented step-child, and my Dad was seemingly unaware of how I was treated. In turn, I put up with a lot of emotional abuse. I left one home where I dodged bullets, and entered another where I tiptoed around landmines. Because of this, I still get weepy when my female friends treat their stepchildren like their own. I heal when my best friend helps her step-son apply for his OSAP, or when I get a text that she’s emotional because she’s moving him to his college home. He’s too grown up. Where did the years go? Where’s the little boy she’s proudly helped to raise?

Another close friend is going through an awful heartbreak, and I genuinely believe a huge part of her sorrow, confusion and despair is that her ex’s son is no longer a staple in her life. Who says a child must grow inside your own body to deserve love, affection and a safe place? Not me. Not ever.

You can imagine how it affected me - that my own two parents didn’t make me feel these things - and to top that, my Dad’s partner didn’t fill in any gaps, either. I grew in an environment of doubt, insecurity, desperation and fear. I don’t say that lightly, as I know it’s a heavy thing to hear. I’m also not asking for pity, because it’s no longer hurting me. I don’t resent it, either (and don’t think I ever even did) but I do embrace how that environment has affected me as a grown woman. I can’t change it, so why harbour hatred towards it? I do own it, and thus understand who I am now because of it. And you know something? I could be worse. Things could always be worse. And quite honestly, I’m proud of how I turned out.

I have a lot of others to thank for this. Many I’ve mentioned or written about in the past, so I won’t harp on that now. But when friends, my husband, or my sweet Gramma ask how I turned out the way I did I rhyme off all the reasons I assume; part of it is beating odds, some of it is proving my disbelievers wrong, a huge portion of it is the love and support I got from other families and mentors in my life.

But the biggest ticket of all? Choices. I chose to not be hateful. I let it soften me, instead of hardening me. I let it make me sensitive, instead of cold. I put my heart out in the open, strapped onto my sleeve, instead of locking it up and away. It made me raw and open instead of closed and sealed. I chose to be this way, and yes I’m imperfect, but I know what could have happened alternatively. I’ve taught it. I’ve met it. And put simply, I’m glad I escaped it.

I may have made these choices long ago - long before I even knew what I was doing - but it’s never too late. I so often hear people making excuses for others; “you know what her Mom is like”, “he didn’t have grandparents”, “they didn’t have money”, “her Dad was an alcoholic”, “his Mom was abusive”, etc., etc.

I could make my own list of reasons I should be different, but instead I guess I’ve climbed those hurdles like stairs to higher ground, as opposed to stairs into a darker, deeper place. I refuse to belittle others, act selfishly, or abuse people (or substances) because my life was ‘so unfair’. Or because that’s all I knew. Or because that’s easier. I am a product of my gene pools, my raising, and my choices. I clung to the good, and when it wasn’t there, I made the good myself.

As an adult, I can now see pretty clearly the traits I’ve inherited from both of my parents. The good, and what you would call ‘the bad’. I can also see how my raising has affected and shaped me (for the good, and the bad, as well). I can also pinpoint where I’ve made choices to pick up that apple and move it (yes, for the good and bad). In the end, I’m proud (most of the time) of who I am, where I am, and what I’ve become.

To start, there’s the ‘nature’ part of the debate. The part of me that’s in my genes; my wiring - my chemistry.

I am my mother’s daughter;

-          I tell overly long and drawn out stories, where I should be more succinct.
-          I sometimes lose my cool when under pressure (the difference being that mine comes out as anxiety or emotion as opposed to anger and blame)
-          I like being different from the status quo, challenging expected and accepted norms, and befriending ‘odd’ and ‘unique’ individuals, because they spice up my life (and I am one, too).
-          I am insanely loyal as a friend, and tend to give all of myself to those I love. The only thing I ask for in return is respect and appreciation, no tabs taken. When I’m taken for granted or mistreated, it (sorry for my lack of better language) eventually pisses me off. In my ripe old age, I lose my patience with this more quickly. Don’t be surprised if you don’t see me or hear from me as much. My Mom stormed off with zest and vigour, leaving fires and dust in her path. I tend to bow out quietly through a back door. My new way of explaining this phenomenon? Don’t burn ‘our bridge’ and then expect me to swim across to you. Signal wiping hands clean motion, here.
-          I am silly and outgoing when in the company of children, and/or people I feel I can be my true self with.
-          I love to write.
-          I love to dance.
-          I love live music.
-          I love to garden.
-          I love being outdoors (and everything ‘nature’)
-          I love being near water.
-          I love to cook, experiment with new recipes, and to dine out in new places.
-          I love musicals and plays.
-          I love hotel stays.
-          I relish my ‘me’ time, and appreciate my time spent alone.
-          I’m passive aggressive when I’m offended or don’t know how to approach a difficult situation (not because I want to be, but because I don’t know how to cope with confrontation). Reminder: I am an only child, to a single parent, who never played competitive sports, and grew up in a very, very small town.

If you knew her, and know me, you may be able to add to this list. To the good, and the bad, which I embrace. She was an incredible woman who I am grateful to have called ‘Mom’. As Jill Churchill once said, “there is no way to be a perfect mother, and a million ways to be a good one”. This comforts me now, knowing that very soon I’m going to be a mother, too. My Mom was exceptional, as I’ve mentioned. Despite our difficulties, those are the memories I relish and hold most dear.

I am also my father’s daughter. I have never lived with my Dad for any length of time to have been truly ‘socialized’ by him. When reflecting on my Mom’s influence, there are grey areas and blurred lines where I wonder whether it’s genes or her influence. Alternatively, with my similarities to my Dad, I know it’s more likely because of our genes. In the past 15 years, as I’ve been able to get to know him better, our likenesses are blaring. I used to think I became who I am in opposition to who my Mom could be, and now I know that is only partially true. And, my similarities to my Dad may have been some of the main reasons my Mom had such a hard time accepting and loving me, as I was a constant reminder of him. I guess we’ll never know! And maybe, just maybe, she didn’t even fully realize it.

My “I’m just like my Dad” list goes a bit like this;

-          I’m OCD. I like things to be a certain way, in a certain place, with a certain degree of cleanliness. I can be hard to live with because of this, but please know, it’s not a choice I make. It’s in my bones. I wish I could let go of this control, but it isn’t a switch. It’s better than living with a slob though, right? I always thought it was just me creating order in an otherwise chaotic life. That is only part of the big picture.
-          I keep lists and notes for myself. Sticky notes can be found in every room of our home.
-          I have a dirty sense of humour (please note – I am not ashamed of this – but my language and crude and uncensored revelations may catch you off guard)
-          I make friends easily, and am content to carry on random and friendly conversations with strangers.
-          It’s hard for me to pick one vocation, and feel I’m ‘good at’ and ‘enjoy’ too many things to commit to just one.
-          I may not have a lot, but I also don’t need a lot.
-          I may not have a lot, but I’ll help you out and be there for you the best way I possibly can.
-          I’d rather be content and have an even pace in my life than be strung out, overworked, and rich.
-          I lose my cool when under pressure, and can get frustrated easily. I won’t take it out on you, but it may seem like I’m mad at you when I’m actually not.
-          I have an open and tender heart, no matter how tough I may seem.
-          I bounce back from and overcome struggles with an optimistic and grateful attitude.

Again, if you know him, and you know me, you may be able to add to the good and bad of this list. At this stage of my life (at the age of 30) I’ve never been so grateful to have my Dad in my life. He lives all of 15 minutes away (the closest he’s ever lived) and we spend more quality time together now than we ever have. Not having my Mom or a ‘full’ sibling I see regularly, plus with expecting my first child in under 2 months, it couldn’t come at a better time.

I embrace how I’m like him, I appreciate our similarities (not everyone ‘gets it’ like he does, cares, or tries), and I savour our times together. He gets agitated faster than most people I know, but never with ill intention, and yet he calms me better, just by being there, than anyone else can.

If I held our many years of a fragmented connection against him, think of what we’d be missing. If I held a grudge for how his partner of 10 years treated me, and in turn, manipulated him, who would win? At the end of the day, he’s my Dad, and I love him.

Looking deeper, my parents are the way they are because of this same chain reaction and chemistry of genes and raising. Too many people look at and judge others for their face value, without asking prodding questions (openly, or through silent reflection). I have been blessed to build and cherish relationships with all 4 of my grandparents throughout my life, which has given me a more whole and rich understanding of my parents. Only my maternal grandmother is still living, but all of them have shaped and influenced me directly and indirectly, in good ways, and bad. I can’t change that, or deny that, so why not embrace it, reflect on it, question it, and see it fully so as to better understand myself.

To support my point, there are some ‘simple’, taken for granted things that I know had a huge effect on my parents and who they turned out to be;

My Mom was raised by a father who grew up in a very poor and very abusive situation. One where you worked your tail off, lived in fear, weren’t allowed to ‘enjoy’ or have fun, and punishment and shame were expected and practiced regularly. Her mother grew in an environment where there was love and respect, but not affection. My grandmother’s mother lost her mother at a young age, which forced her to raise her own brothers and look after her Dad. Her nurturer was gone, and she did what she had to. My Gramma will still get emotional when speaking about her parents and how wonderful they were, and yet they rarely if ever hugged her or told her they loved her. This all helps me understand my own mother, and how she expressed her love in the best way she knew how, so much better.

On my maternal grandfather’s side there is a history of alcohol abuse and mental health issues. The 2 often go hand in hand, even in modern day. The former is a choice, but is often an escape from the latter. Thankfully, so far, both have skipped me. I have no interest in drinking to escape anything. I drink socially, to celebrate, and because I genuinely love the taste of beer, wine, and some spirits. I’ve never gotten drunk alone, or been hurtful to anyone when not sober. This is where, thankfully, I’m more like my Dad.

Another huge event that shaped my Gramma, and thus her role as a mother, was her third child only lived about a week. My Mom told me of how beautiful she remembers Julie Ann to be. She was a perfect porcelain doll baby sister. My Mom was only 4 or 5, and only met her once. Julie was taken from my Gramma and sent to Sick Kids Hospital, back in the 50s. She didn’t make it, and my Gramma never saw her baby again. They buried a newborn sized coffin, without ever seeing its contents, and my Mom and her older brother were sent to stay with their grandparents for some time to let the dust settle at home. When my Mom got home, she never could understand where her perfect baby sister disappeared to. You didn’t talk about it, you didn’t fuss over it, you moved on. My Gramma credits her mother for pulling her out of her misery, and I am always amazed at how she did this; my Great Gramma Laura came over with floor wax and the two of them waxed the hardwood floors. That’s what snapped my Gramma out of her grief, and life went on as normal. I know I could never have recovered so quickly or stoically. But, knowing these truths helps me understand my Gramma, and my Mom, so much more.

My Mom was also a January 10th baby. She was one of the oldest in her class, and was smart as a whip (without even trying). This, I might add, is a trait I didn’t get from her. She even skipped grade 3, due to her level of intelligence, and often challenged authority members and the expected norms with a quick wit and daring attitude. She was admired, and feared, because she was a trailblazer who lived outside of the box.

My Dad, on the other hand, was a December 14th baby. As a teacher, I know this means he was one of the youngest in his class, and a boy, which makes learning more difficult (especially early on). To top that, from what I hear, he was quite a Mama’s boy and was very shy at a young age. He was also very close with his aunts and uncles, of which he had plenty, and preferred spending time doing hands-on work on their farms. He had a lot of friends, but spent much of his weekends and summers helping his family members with chores, learning how to shoot a rifle, or fishing in the creek at the back end of his grandparents’ farm. An academic environment was not a place he thrived, because it didn’t lend itself to his preferential learning style. He also challenged authority with his trouble-maker humour and avoidance strategies. He tells so many stories of the crazy things he pulled as a child and teenager. Some are so seemingly far-fetched they are hard to believe. But, as I’ve been told, there’s no reason to not believe him, as they’re actually all true. He’s lucky to even be alive, and should really consider writing a book documenting his many adventures.

Something he has remarked about, which I never used to consider, is that he was raised as one of four boys. He admits that the presence of a sister would have really altered the family dynamic, and his choices and behaviours.

To this day, I don’t know how my Grandma did it. You can imagine her joy when her first grandchild was born, and it was a girl. Her love, affection and adoration was part of the foundation that has kept me whole.

As you can tell, I’ve taken a lot into consideration. I don’t know if others have done so to the extent that I have, but if you haven’t, I encourage it. Ask questions while you can. Don’t judge or assume based on face-value. Look deeply at your roots; they go deeper than you think. Our lives are tangled webs we’re born into. We learn to navigate them the best way we know how, and weave our own influences into the pattern as well. We are as much a product of our parents’ genes and our raising as we are our choices, and we should constantly reflect on whether we’re proud of who we are and what we’ve become.

I’ve had to become a peaceful participant in that area of my life, too. I struggled - and still do sometimes - with the contrast between my social successes versus my professional ones. I’m typically quite proud of who I am as a daughter, wife, friend, grand-daughter, niece, aunt, etc., as I do most things that involve ‘people’ with good intention. But, my success career and money-wise doesn’t always measure up. Again, the choices I’ve made in this area have been influenced by my circumstances, which I continue to grapple with and navigate, but I’m harder on myself than I’ve ever been on any other living thing. I guess in the big picture I’d rather be a kind person than a rich one, but rational me and emotional me don’t always see eye to eye.

On the bright side, I’m young. I’m still so young, and have so much future to look forward to. In just over a month I will hold my very own child in my arms, and after some ‘light reflection’, I’ve realized that my impact on this impressionable, innocent, and deserving child is significant, to say the least. I am part of a process that began long before my birth, and the chain links will continue to be added as time ticks on. I need to be aware of how my genes, my actions, and my choices affect this person. There were too many times when I would say to my Mom - in her more desperate moments - that I hadn’t chosen to be born. I must remember this; we choose to have babies, they don’t choose us. We must be parents worth loving and respecting, despite the odds and influences.

My choices to date have been (mostly) good ones. One of the best I ever made was to date my husband. Another was my agreeing to marry him. And the latest? Finally taking the leap and becoming a Mom.

It used to terrify me. I don’t say this lightly, either. It overwhelmed me beyond explanation, and didn’t ignite a desire in me worth pursuing for a long time.

I used to see it as a burden. I feared the drastic change. I avoided the responsibility. I questioned my reasons. I doubted my abilities.

And then something changed.

I can’t put my finger on it, define it, or explain it. But, I’m glad. I’ve never felt so whole in my life. I’ve never felt so important, or blessed. I’ve never felt so proud, or excited.

I now see being a mother as an honour, not a chore, and I recognize that I am a small part of a very big puzzle. Part nature, part nurture, and part choice.

What a gift to know that our baby was hoped for, tried for, and sought after. I didn’t have that luxury, as the child to my parents, but you can bet I’m healing from this angle, in this newfound role.

Our baby is wanted and cherished by both of its parents.
Our child will never question that. Ever. I’ll see to it. I’m making that choice.










No comments:

Post a Comment